Print Options:

Deli Style Red Potato Salad

Yields1 Serving

An iconic red-skinned potato salad.

Ingredients
 2 lbs waxy new red potatoes
 Salt (for the potato water), about 2 tsp
 2 tsp vinegar
 4 hard-boiled eggs, sliced
 4 stalks celery, sliced into thin crescents
 1 cup deli style salad dressing , or to taste
 2 tbsp chopped fresh dill, or up to 2 tsp dried
 chopped red onion to taste
Directions
1

Let's ignore all those potato pundits that tell us to use russets. Find some nice new red potatoes. If they're not the small creamer variety, cut them up into uniform large chunks.

Start the potatoes in cold salted water, bring to a boil quickly, then simmer with care. You might say they're done when they slip off a small, sharp knife. You might also say they're done, authoritatively, when the temperature in the center hits 205 degrees. You might notice that this takes around 15 or 20 minutes. You can also just taste one.

Drain the potatoes and put them in a big bowl. While they are still hot, sprinkle with the vinegar and toss them around a bit. Let cool completely. Slice them into rounds, add the other ingredients, and store in the fridge, well wrapped, until ready to serve. With an hour or so to go, add the dressing and mix well but gently.

Gratuities

2

Potato salad in the north attracts the same kind of patriotic mysticism as grits in the south. I can't believe how many recipes out there call specifically for russets (aka Idaho) potatoes vs. my beloved redskins.

But now that I have that off my chest - yukon gold potatoes do work well, but they don't look as festive. I love red onion in potato salad; my wife doesn't. Bacon is great - of course. Crisp up two slices per pound of potatoes. I think I made this salad once with sauteed, crisped proscuitto and peas. Maybe it was just a dream, but that does sound good. All of these are meant to go with the extra-sweet, extra-salty, extra-creamy deli dressing linked above. Potato salad using homemade mayo is something else entirely. Something French.

I think eggs are important. We could go on and on about this, but I'll just tell you: don't boil them at all. Put a steamer basket in a covered saucepan and build up a nice head of steam. Pierce the eggs in the dull end. Steam them, covered, for 10 minutes exactly, fish them out into a bowl and run cold water over them for a minute or two. Add ice to the bowl if you want to use them right away, and let them sit for 5 or ten minutes.

The big thing about steamed eggs is that the shell never sticks to the top layer of white. The big thing about 10 minutes is that, apparently, eggs understand the decimal system. Regardless of size and initial temperature, after 10 minutes of steaming the eggs are perfectly cooked, with no trace of gray around the yolk, and a small sphere of creaminess in the very center. I'm kidding. But not really; this pretty much works.

It's good not to make potato salad too far ahead. It gets watery, and the blush of youth fades. Having pre-made dressing on hand saves last-minute measuring, ensures a fresh-tasting salad, and lets you set the richness level you desire.